GRANT ASSESSMENT

Guideline
Position statement and recommendations for research assessment processes
To provide a framework within which research performing and research funding organisations can adapt their assessment processes and collaborate to reduce increasing strains on the system and tackle challenges faced.
The recommendations are based on a major fact-finding study, supplemented by an extensive consultation process. They represent current best practices implemented in Science Europe member organisations and can be considered the current gold standard in research assessment methods. They provide a framework within which all research organisations can further develop and optimise their own processes. At the same time, there is a need to consider how assessment processes should evolve in the future to ensure that they remain effective. The recommendations provide a starting point from which broader reforms to such processes can be considered. It is important to recognise that these recommendations are primarily about assessment processes and methods, and not so much about criteria. In recent times, the appropriateness of various criteria (such as journal metrics) has been questioned through initiatives such as the San Francisco Declaration on Research Assessment and the Leiden Manifesto on Research Metrics. This is a highly relevant debate, where a careful separation of assessment processes and criteria needs to be made.
Reference of the resource
Position Statement and Recommendations on Research Assessment Processes, Science Europe 2020.
Type of resource:
Guideline
Relevant discipline(s):
All
Relevant stakeholder(s):
Post-graduate students
PhD candidates
Early career researchers
Senior researchers
Supervisors
Funders
Relevant organisational level(s):
System (macro level)
Institution (meso level)
Published/put into force:
2020